James Petigru Boyce, A Southern Baptist Statesman, Tom Nettles

   If you've kept up with my reviews of the other volumes from this series then you know that I am in love with the series, American Reformed Biographies. I recently acquired all the current biographies in this series and have slated them for upcoming reading adventures! My interest in J.P. Boyce has been a long-standing one. He is a figure in Baptist history that, to my mind, modeled so much of what Baptists should strive for in ministry. For some time I've desired to learn more about this great father of the Southern Baptist denomination. When I saw that the American Reformed Biography series had included a J.P. Boyce edition I was ecstatic. Finally, I thought, we will get a quality biography about this giant of a man whom so few Southern Baptist know anything about. 

   For the most part, having now read this edition, my joy remains. It is good and right that Boyce was included in this series. It is also good and right that Dr. Tom Nettles was selected to write it. It is worth the read and has much to commend it to both Baptist and other Evangelicals. Boyce's contribution is highlighted and celebrated. There is much to be learned about the beginning and struggling years of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. Of great interest to me was that Nettles included some information about life for Boyce and Southern Baptists during the Civil War. So, the diligent reader will find much to keep him "hooked" till the end. 

   With all the aforementioned said I am painfully compelled to point out a few criticisms. First, I must say that the constant reports about who gave how much to the seminary, how much they were short to pay the professors and how far Boyce and others had to travel to convince someone to give was exhausting. It is understandable to include this in some way in an abbreviated fashion but the repetition of this information made me feel as though this were the first biography ever written from an accountant's ledger. It just did not make for interesting reading. Furthermore, this emphasis made the biography feel like it was as much, if not more, about the founding and financing of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary than it was about the man James Petigru Boyce. Frankly, I wanted to know the man more. I desired to know more about J.P. Boyce. How can learn from him and grow from his life? The seminary is an interest of mine as well but not to the shadowing of the man who founded it. Then there was the constant appearance or assumption we might say, of A.T. Robertson with no introduction or explanation. Of course, I am familiar with A.T. Robertson and his mammoth works. Robertson is another of the Southern Baptist greats that have been all but forgotten to the lust for growth and change that have taken hold in the denomination (topic for another time).

   With this trajectory, this biography has little excuse to justify its length. When the Van Til and Nevin volumes are 200 pages shorter it is hard to understand why this edition is so long. Why not cut out some of the ledger reporting? If all we were going to do is report where Boyce picked up another $1000 then, by all means, I vote that we keep it brief. Don't get me wrong; I have great respect for the author. Maybe that's the reason for my disappointment. My appreciation for Dr. Nettles possibly raised my expectations too high. I admit that my entry thought was: "Finally, a biography about an exceptional Baptist leader that is written exceptionally." But my exit from the book was not with so much excitement. It is worth the read but it does often become tedious and for that, I am bothered. 

Post tenebras lux, 

Scott